Refinancing

Refinance an ARM to Fixed: Reading the Reset, Caps and Break-Even

Weighing a refinance from an ARM to a fixed rate? How to read the reset date and rate caps in the loan papers, run break-even math and weigh the trade.

Branded Iron Hill Mortgage graphic for "Refinance an ARM to Fixed: Reading the Reset, Caps and Break-Even", listing the topics covered: When does it make sense to refinance an ARM to a fixed rate?; What notices come before an ARM adjusts?; How do you run break-even math on an ARM-to-fixed refinance?.

Homeowners who refinance an ARM to a fixed rate are usually trading an unknown future payment for a known one. Whether that trade makes sense depends on when the adjustable rate resets, how far the caps let it move, what the new loan costs and how long the owner plans to keep the home.

The Iron Hill Brief has covered how an adjustable-rate mortgage resets and the general mechanics of a rate-and-term refinance. This guide looks at the decision itself.

When does it make sense to refinance an ARM to a fixed rate?

Start with the loan papers. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains that when the initial rate on an adjustable-rate mortgage expires, the new rate is the index plus the margin, subject to any rate caps. The index moves with market conditions; the margin is set by the lender at the start and stays in the note.

The caps set the range. The CFPB describes three kinds:

  • Initial adjustment cap: how much the rate can change the first time it adjusts. The CFPB says two or five percentage points is common.
  • Subsequent adjustment cap: how much it can change at each later adjustment, most commonly one or two percentage points.
  • Lifetime cap: how much it can change over the life of the loan, most commonly five percentage points above or below the initial rate, though some loans have a higher cap.

Those terms show the worst case. If the owner can afford the highest payment the caps allow and expects to sell before many adjustments, keeping the ARM may still be reasonable. If the capped payment would strain the budget, or the owner plans to stay for many years, a fixed rate removes that uncertainty.

What notices come before an ARM adjusts?

Federal rules require advance notice. Under Regulation Z, the servicer must send a notice of the first rate adjustment at least 210, but no more than 240, days before the first payment at the new level is due. Each adjustment that changes the payment also brings a notice, generally at least 60, but no more than 120, days before the new payment is due. Either notice is a prompt to review the options while there is still time to shop.

How do you run break-even math on an ARM-to-fixed refinance?

Break-even is the closing costs of the new loan divided by the monthly savings. As an illustration only, $4,000 in closing costs divided by $100 a month in savings is 40 months. The Iron Hill refinance break-even calculator runs the same arithmetic with your own numbers.

An ARM-to-fixed refinance does not always lower the payment. If the fixed rate offered today is higher than the ARM's current rate, there are no monthly savings to recover the costs. The comparison then is between the fixed payment and the payment the ARM could reach under its caps, plus the value of knowing the payment will not change. Check the loan papers for any prepayment penalty as well; Regulation Z requires the adjustment notice to say when one may apply.

Frequently asked questions

Can I refinance an ARM before it adjusts?

Generally yes, subject to qualifying for the new loan and any prepayment penalty in the current note. Many owners start shopping when the first adjustment notice arrives.

What if fixed rates are higher than my ARM rate today?

The refinance may raise the payment now. The decision then rests on how high the ARM could go under its caps and how long you plan to keep the home.

Where do I find my ARM's caps and margin?

They are in the promissory note and the loan's closing documents. Your servicer can also confirm them.

Sources

For general information only, not a commitment to lend or an offer of credit. Loan programs, terms, and eligibility vary and are subject to approval.

Iron Hill Mortgage NMLS #1946451 · NMLS Consumer Access (opens in a new tab) · Equal Housing Opportunity

Talk it through with our team

Book a short call, or text us your question. We'll explain your options in plain language.

Call or text (615) 949-4780 · Answered 24/7 for booking

Booked calls are with a member of the Iron Hill team. Home loans are handled by a licensed loan officer.